Showing posts with label labor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label labor. Show all posts

Friday, June 10, 2016

Uber Disrupts Organized Labor

While disrupting the car-for-hire industry with its ride-sharing app, Uber created a new level of job flexibility and choice for the people who drive for them, allowing drivers to set their own hours and essentially be their own bosses. And now, Uber is doing something similar to the standard union model.

In early May, Uber announced it had reached a deal with the International Association of Machinists District 15 to form the Independent Drivers Guild for New York City’s 35,000 Uber drivers.

What makes the Guild interesting is, although organized by a large labor union, it won’t look much like a typical union. The New York Times  reported that the Guild, “would establish a forum for regular dialogue and afford [workers] some limited benefits and protections — but that would stop short of unionization.”

The five-year agreement would allow members regular meetings with management, an appeals process for discipline and access to several benefits programs such as insurance and legal services.

Even though Guild members will meet with Uber, they will not be able to force Uber to bargain over contracts as a traditional union would. Further, no Uber driver will be required to pay dues to the Guild, as they otherwise would in a traditional union in New York. Uber drivers could still work directly with the company and would not need to go through the Guild if they wanted to negotiate with management or appeal a grievance on their own. 

The Guild and Uber will team up to lobby for a level playing field on taxi sales taxes. Currently New York state law charges a 9 percent sales tax on Uber rides but there is only a 50-cent surcharge on taxicabs.

According to Uber Chief Advisor David Plouffe, rides with Uber and taxis should be taxed at the same rate. “This would not only mean more money for drivers, it would also free up resources for a new benefits fund administered by the Guild and used to cover benefits such as paid time off or parental leave, for example.”

 While the deal is not perfect, it shows the beginning of a model that could bring unionization into the 21st Century. It also signals that at least a few unions are taking seriously the new on-demand, independent contractor economy, which is likely to continue growing.

Starting with the good: almost all of the agreement between Uber and IAM is voluntary. The agreement does not force drivers to be represented by the union, nor does it compel the company to bargain, as is standard operating procedure with traditional unions. Instead, the agreement models a “members-only agreement,“ where a union in a workplace only represents the workers who choose to become members of the union.

As a result, Uber will work with IAM but is not legally required to do so. Rather, the company and the union will work together because it is in both of their own interest to do so. To the extent that the Guild helps make Uber a more attractive job opportunity, it will help the company gain better contractors, provide better services and best its competition.

Natalie Foster, cofounder of Peers.org, a company that provides portable health and life insurance and retirement options for workers in the sharing economy, highlighted in a piece for CNN.com the benefits and flexibility the Guild would provide Uber drivers. She says the arrangement has the “potential to be a critical step toward a 21st century safety net for American workers’ real lives today, because it could very well lead to a workable model to provide portable benefits to gig economy workers.”

The benefits of the deal for the union is that it gets the potential of dues-paying members (IAM is not charging fees for membership as of the announcement) and only has to provide services to workers who are members.

Not all unions are willing to adapt to the sharing economy and embrace the voluntary approach of the Guild. Bhairavi Desai, executive director of the New York Taxi Workers Alliance, told Reuters the deal was a “historic betrayal” of drivers since IAM gave up they type of mandatory association experienced by traditional unions. The Taxi Workers Alliance filed a class action lawsuit in Federal Court in New York on June 2nd to reclassify Uber drivers as employees as opposed to independent contractors.

But now for the bad in the deal: the Uber-IAM deal could open the door for compulsory funding of the union through this newly created union-controlled benefits fund.  If Uber and the Guild successfully lobby to reduce the sales tax on Uber rides, the union could fight to use part of the savings to fund itself though a mandated union benefits fund, rather than allow drivers to keep the extra earnings and choose whether or not to contribute.

Clearly the playing field should be level and taxis should not be given special tax benefits in comparison to Uber or any other private hire vehicles, so the arbitrary sales tax on Uber rides should be eliminated. But any savings should go to benefit drivers and they should decide if they’d like to use that extra income to pay into the Guild’s benefits fund.

Further, the new innovative Guild could be no more than a stalking horse for a traditional union.

Jim Conigliaro Jr, general counsel for the IAM District 15, has clearly stated that if Uber drivers are redefined as “employees,” his union would try to organize them into a traditional union.

Nevertheless, the IAM and Uber coming to a voluntary agreement to provide optional benefits for drivers suggests the potential start of a positive transition for the labor movement. The voluntary agreement shows that unions no longer need to compel employers and employees into accepting forced representation and paying forced dues in order to support themselves. And if successful, this deal would demonstrate that unions do not need to use legislative and regulatory action to reclassify independent contractor and small business owners into a one-size-fits-all category they can then organize for the purpose of collecting dues.

If there are no ulterior motives to force unwanted representation on Uber drivers, and the plan is simply to provide a service that drivers can accept or reject then, except for the possibility of forcing drivers to contribute to an IAM controlled benefits fund the agreement between Uber and IAM should be applauded.

Original Source

Contact Neil O'Toole and John Sbarbaro
Phone: 303-595-4777
Located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 

Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.


Privacy Policy

Wednesday, February 10, 2016

Uber Drivers Have No Right to Strike

Some Uber drivers in New York City went on strike this week, after the company reduced rates on its basic service, UberX, in New York City by 15 percent. The protest was planned by a group of drivers known as the United Drivers Network over fare cuts and overall deteriorating conditions.

Uber was pleased with the results of the new rates saying drivers spent 39 percent less time without a fare and saw a 20 percent increase in hourly earnings compared with two weekends earlier.

Many drivers disagree. In fact, one was quoted as saying, “We can’t understand how we’re going to make more money if the fares are less and we have to work twice as hard to be making the same money.”

The Solution
Uber drivers have no right to strike and should be thankful for their jobs. The solution is getting passed this typical union bullying mentality. If the drivers don’t agree with the compensation they receive, don’t drive for Uber. If you’re not happy, go find another job. Compensation is based on supply and demand, and Uber is no more obligated to over pay for labor than Microsoft, Johnson & Johnson or Apple.

Unfortunately, we could see more of this. In Seattle, the city council voted unanimously in December to extend collective bargaining powers to drivers for services like Uber and Lyft. It became the first city to unionize Uber drivers.

The unionized mentality has to stop. It’s another archaic American institution that served a purpose in a bygone era and should be buried with the dead. Workers have become spoiled with inflated wages, tenure, and guaranteed work based on every factor outside of job performance and results.

A few years ago, I was in Madison, Wisconsin, at the time teachers went on strike. I talked to more than a dozen teachers. All of them told me the same thing: they said they had the right to collective bargaining and to their job. When I asked them where job performance fit into the equation, I barely got a reply. They looked at me as though they didn’t understand the question. And that’s one of the biggest problems unions create: the idea that they have a right to a job, like it’s an entitlement awarded at birth.

If you want to earn more money, bullying your employer with a mob isn’t the answer. Production is. If you want to earn more money, provide more service. End of story.

Unfortunately, some drivers want to cause even more trouble. The Uber Driver’s Network Facebook page posted this message yesterday:

Fellow Drivers,
We have some B I G PLANS mapped out for the next few days. Please be ready to take more MASSIVE action that will shake Uber to its core foundation and everyone who supports them in their oppression against drivers. The fight has just begun: if what we did this past Monday was massive (#1 Trend on Facebook and still #3 World Wide News coverage), then W A I T and see what we have planned next [If I was Uber, I’d really rethink my strategies and clean house if necessary of those advising with destroying the lives of drivers and their families]. What’s next you ask? something that will S T R I K E at the core.

Uber drivers: stop being stupid, grow up emotionally and if you want to make more money, go out and make more money. This is America, a free-market economy, the land of opportunity and you can earn as much as you want. Become an entrepreneur, start your own car service or other company and go conquer the American dream. Going on strike in front of your company’s headquarters and inconveniencing customers is not the answer.

Original Source

Contact Neil O'Toole and John Sbarbaro
Phone: 303-595-4777
Located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 

Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.


Privacy Policy

Thursday, April 10, 2014

Overworked America: 12 Charts That Will Make Your Blood Boil

Why "efficiency" and "productivity" really mean more profits for corporations and less sanity for you.









Want more rage? We've got 12 charts that show how the superrich spoil it for the rest of us.
In the past 20 years, the US economy has grown nearly 60 percent. This huge increase in productivity is partly due to automation, the internet, and other improvements in efficiency. But it's also the result of Americans working harder—often without a big boost to their bottom lines. Oh, and meanwhile, corporate profits are up 20 percent. (Also read ouressay on the great speedup and harrowing first-person tales of overwork.)

YOU HAVE NOTHING TO LOSE BUT YOUR GAINS

Productivity has surged, but income and wages have stagnated for most Americans. If the median household income had kept pace with the economy since 1970, it would now be nearly $92,000, not $50,000.

GROWTH IS BACK...

...BUT JOBS AREN'T

SORRY, NOT HIRING

The sectors that have contributed the most to the country's overall economic growth have lagged when it comes to creating jobs.

THE WAGE FREEZE

Increase in real value of the minimum wage since 1990: 21%
Increase in cost of living since 1990: 67%
One year's earnings at the minimum wage:$15,080
Income required for a single worker to have real economic security: $30,000

WORKING 9 TO 7

For Americans as a whole, the length of a typical workweek hasn't changed much in years. But for many middle-class workers, job obligations are creeping into free time and family time. For low-income workers, hours have declined due to a shrinking job market, causing underemployment.

LABOR PAINS

Median yearly earnings of:
Union workers: $47,684
Non-union workers: $37,284

DUDE, WHERE'S MY JOB?

More and more, US multinationals are laying off workers at home and hiring overseas.

PROUD TO BE AN AMERICAN

The US is part of a very small club of nations that don't require...

DIGITAL OVERTIME

A survey of employed email users finds:
22% are expected to respond to work email when they're not at work.
50% check work email on the weekends.
46% check work email on sick days.
34% check work email while on vacation.

THE SECOND SHIFT

Working moms pick up more child care and household duties than working dads—about 80 minutes more every day. Meanwhile, dads enjoy nearly 50 more minutes of watching TV and other leisure activities on a daily basis.

CHORE WARS

Thanks, guys—you're pitching in more than twice as much as you did in the '70s. But women still get stuck with the majority of work around the house.

















Sources
GDP/jobs: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development; Stephen Gordon, Université Laval
50 hours: Center for American Progress (PDF)
Second shift: Bureau of Labor Statistics (PDF)
Contact Neil O'Toole and John Sbarbaro
Phone: 303-595-4777
Located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 

Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.


Privacy Policy

Friday, September 13, 2013

Fast Food Strippers Will Solve Our Labor Strife - The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. - Workers Compensation Denver, Colorado

By  

My God, I am freaking brilliant. In the blink of an eye, I took two major labor stories that have been in the news of late, combined them, and simultaneously solved two controversial labor issues. This is yet another idea for which I’ll probably be awarded a Nobel Prize. Or a Pulitzer. Maybe a Booby – whatever organization gives out awards for solving labor issues no one else wants to address.
The last few weeks there has been a chorus of protest that fast food and Walmart workers in this country need to be paid a “livable” wage, instead of the paltry minimum wage this country mandates. This cacophonous disruption is coming from groups around the nation including academics, intellectuals, union workers, fast food workers, national media, and other people who do not understand what an entry level job is. The amount most often cited as a “livable wage” is $15 per hour. Let me assure you, that is about what I make, and it is livable so long as you work over 90 hours a week. 
Also in the news this week is a group of strippers that successfully won a class action suit against an adult entertainment company, entitling them to be classified as employees, and thereby requiring them to be paid, get this, minimum wage.  This despite the fact that some of them in court proceedings admitted to earning up to $1,000 a night in tips. I’m wondering if that is the same thing they told the IRS… 
Anyway, we now find ourselves in the untenable position of recognizing that fast food and Walmart workers are entitled to $15 an hour, but strippers are only going to get minimum wage. 
I don’t think that is fair. Strippers are willing to give their all, or bare it, anyway, in the goal of total customer satisfaction. They are willing to go to the mat, literally in some cases, to see their customer leaves with an infectious smile, or at least something that is infectious. This may seem like a victory for them, but it is truly a step backwards.
Enter my simplistic yet brilliant solution. We simply combine the job codes. We make fast food and Walmart workers strippers. Think of it; they would make at least $15 an hour, and the required offset in prices would be much more palatable. Many customers in this scenario wouldn’t mind shelling out $8 for a Big Mac or Whopper. Come to think of it, Big Mac and Whopper could take on different meanings in this environment, so we had best be careful. Other phrases with potentially significant changes in fast food lexicon would be “supersize me”, “special sauce” and “would you like fries with that”. It should also go without saying that the position of Walmart greeter would quickly become the most popular one in the store. 
The Happy Meal would become the Happy Ending Meal. And it would cost $200. This would probably even change the type of little toy that is included with the box.
Other impacts - There would be required some fairly significant safety modifications, particularly around the deep fryers and grill area. Workers’ comp would be a definitive concern, especially if the wrong buns end up getting toasted. Finding a place to clip those unwieldy Walmart name badges would be a challenge. Over time we could see an improvement in the health of customers, since virtually no one would use the drive thru anymore. Everyone would, for reasons not completely misunderstood, park their cars and walk inside. Fathers would spend more time with their children, or at least be nearby while their kids toiled in the play area or parking lot for hours on end.

Overall, this is a win-win for workers, business and consumerism in general. No need to thank me. For me it is just all in a day’s work. Although I would like a Nobel or Pulitzer on my desk. I need something substantive to keep all the papers from sliding around. Probably just end up with a Booby, but if my fast food stripper plan works out they will be much easier to come by.
Original Source

The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. can help you with your workers' compensation or Social Security disability case.
http://www.otoole-sbarbaro.com
Phone: 303-595-4777
We are located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 
Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.

Privacy Policy