Showing posts with label work comp claim. Show all posts
Showing posts with label work comp claim. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 1, 2013

Are You Inadvertantly Driving Your Work Comp Costs UP?

By  
When employees can make more staying home than working, there is very little incentive to return to work.

Collateral Source Benefits

A collateral source benefit acts as a “collateral source” of income or perk. It creates a situation where an injured employee has an incentive NOT to work.

While providing certain benefits can foster employee loyalty for many productive years, sometimes these benefits can be offset without a complete injury management program and excellent employee communication.

Involve all departments in designing, administering and maintaining policies. In a large company, human resources, labor and industrial relations, and employee benefits and compensation as well as workers’ comp departments must all be involved. Incentives to remain at and return to work must be built into management systems. Disincentives must be removed from all direct and indirect sources. Substantial savings can be achieved when a company coordinates its salary, benefits and compensation programs so employees are not rewarded by staying out of work.

The following are employee perks that may form disincentives to returning to work:

• Salary and Wage Continuation
Some companies pay 100 percent of salary instead of an employee collecting workers’ compensation for short term injuries.

• Occupational Injury Pay Supplements
Some companies pay supplemental benefits to make up the difference between workers’ compensation benefits and regular earnings.

• Open-Ended Job Return
Holding open an employee’s job indefinitely does not encourage them to return to work as quick as possible. Instead, employers should hold jobs open for a specific time period, such as six or nine months.

• Vacation and Sick Time
Companies frequently allow vacation and sick time to accrue for employees on workers’ compensation. Some even allow employees to “borrow” more sick time if they need to stay out of work longer.

• Short-Term Disability
In some companies, disabled employees receive STD benefits after six weeks. However, the standard definition for the disability policy may differ from that of workers’ comp, allowing an employee to collect both. Combined with some personal insurance policies, this double income means that the worker’s at-home pay exceeds their at-work pay. Eliminate double dipping. Although an employee’s personal insurance is their own, employers should deduct workers’ compensation from other duplicative company payments. Otherwise this encourages malingering.

• Perk Continuation
Employers often maintain ancillary benefits and privileges such as car allowances, club and professional dues, company store privileges and periodical subscriptions for employees on leave.

• Loan Protection Policies
Individual insurance policies are available to pay mortgages and consumer loans such as car loans and credit card debts in the case of a disability. Credit disability insurance may eliminate house and car payments while being unable to work.

• Unemployment Compensation
In a few states, an employee receiving workers’ comp also can qualify for state unemployment benefits under certain circumstances. To prevent this form of double dipping, companies should offer all injured workers transitional jobs they can perform even with their physical restrictions. Under the eligibility rules, workers who refuse such offers will not be deemed unemployed as they must be both able and available for suitable work.

• Pension and Retirement Plans
If these plans do not allow for offset of workers’ comp benefits, an employee can receive workers’ compensation benefits and a full pension.

• Legal Actions
An employee can file a product liability action against the manufacturer of a product that injured him to collect damages. If the employee was injured in a motor vehicle accident, there may be insurance proceeds involved. The employer should seek reimbursement for workers’ comp payment from any such settlement.


To prevent driving up your costs, ask yourself: What Benefits Are Injured Workers Getting by Not Working?

Many companies fail to look closely enough at their internal wage and benefits structure when looking to reduce workers’ compensation costs. Look for these collateral income sources that provide built-in disincentives to remaining injury-free or returning to work. Even such things as reduced childcare and commuting expenses while at home can be disincentives to returning to work.

If not properly coordinated, a company’s employee benefit and compensation programs may inadvertently serve to extend workers’ compensation absences.
Let attorney Neil O'Toole or attorney John Sbarbaro
help you with your workers' compensation or Social Security disability case.
Call the Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. today!
Phone: 303-595-4777
We are located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 
Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.

Privacy Policy

Tuesday, September 10, 2013

Horror Story: What Happens When Modified Duty is Not Provided -Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. Worker's Comp Blog

By 

A recent case in San Diego shows what happens when the adjuster and the employer do not provide Modified Duty.  On August 8, 2013 San Diego District Attorney Bonnie Dumanis announced the guilty pleas of a daughter – father conspiracy to commit workers’ compensation fraud, grand theft and perjury.

Yolandi Kohrumel, age 35, and her father Anton Buitendag, age 65, were sentenced to one year in jail and 180 days in jail, respectively, by the San Diego Superior Court Judge Duane Moring.  Restitution in the full amount the insurer, AIG, had been defrauded, of $1,558,653, was also ordered. 



Worker Claimed Multiple Complications From Injury 

Ms. Kohrumel started work as a store manager for a national office supply company in 2002.  After 3 months on the job, Ms. Kohrumel claimed a box fell on her toe and broke her toe.  In November, 2002, Ms. Kohrumel had surgery on her toe.  Following the toe surgery, she was given crutches.  Ms. Kohrumel claimed she could not use the crutches, and was provided a wheelchair.  The news articles do not address why the third party administrator (TPA) adjuster agreed to a wheelchair instead of having a physical therapist assist the Ms. Kohrumel to learn how to properly use the crutches correctly.  The news article also does not address why the claimant was provided a wheelchair instead of a knee walker for her injured toe. 

Once Ms. Kohrumel had the wheelchair, she alleged she developed carpal tunnel syndrome from using the wheelchair.  The news articles do not address whether or not the TPA adjuster had an Independent Medical Examination (IME) done to confirm the carpal tunnel syndrome claim. [In California IME doctors are called Agreed Medical Evaluators (AME) or if appointed by the Division of Workers’ Compensation, Qualified Medical Evaluators (QME)]. She was provided an electric wheelchair.

The news articles do not explain why neither the TPA adjuster nor the employer arranged for Ms. Kohrumel to work modified duty.  Modified duty for a store manager should have been a no brainer, whether the employee was on crutches, using a knee walker, a standard wheel chair or an electric wheelchair.

Ms. Kohrumel then alleged she developed hypersensitivity to her feet, along with regional pain syndrome, depression and anxiety.  The news articles also do not mention any AMEs or QMEs for the alleged hypersensitivity, regional pain syndrome, depression and anxiety.  In defense of the TPA adjuster, all of Ms. Kohrumel’s doctors believed her subjective claims, or elected not to dispute them.  Still, an AME or QME could have assisted the adjuster to dispute these additional claims. 




Injured Worker Was Receiving 25 Prescriptions From Various Doctors

By 2004, Ms. Kohrumel, who represented herself, was receiving 25 prescriptions from her various doctors.  She alleged she was unable to care for herself and needed 24 hour a day assistance, seven days a week.  With the doctors stating Ms. Kohrumel was permanently disabled, the TPA adjuster agreed for Ms. Kohrumel’s husband to provide her the around the clock care.  Her husband provided the care until his death in September, 2011.  Following her husband’s death, Ms. Kohrumel requested her father, Mr. Buitendag, provide her the around the clock care, to which the adjuster agreed.

Mr. Buitendag felt his services for caring for his daughter were worth $500 per day, or over $182,000 per year.  The TPA adjuster refused to pay the father because he was a foreigner, without a work visa.  At this point, Ms. Kohrumel was represented by an attorney and started litigating the issue before the California Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board.

Ms. Kohrumel decided her residence, a two bedroom apartment, was not large enough for her wheelchair to navigate properly.  The TPA adjuster hired a moving company to relocate Ms. Kohrumel and her father.  The moving company was advised they would have to do everything as Ms. Kohrumel was wheel-chair bound.


Fraud Uncovered Cost Total of $1,500,000

The movers saw Ms. Kohrumel get out of her wheelchair for extended periods, to lift and move heavy boxes in her garage. She was able to move about without any limitations. The movers reported this to the TPA adjuster, who had the movers videotape Ms. Kohrumel as she stood for two hours picking up, moving and sorting through the boxes in her garage.

Investigators for the District Attorney’s Office served a search warrant on Ms. Kohrumel’s garage and found more than 20 boxes of unused prescription medications. The following day, Ms. Kohrumel agreed to enter guilty pleas on 8 felony counts, including grand theft, perjury, false documents and insurance fraud.  Mr. Buitendag pleaded guilty to 3 felonies including attempted grand theft.  The judge in addition to the jail time ordered Ms. Kohrumel to repay the $1,558,653 she had stolen from the insurance company.

Ms. Kohrumel was obviously a person who had no qualms about ripping off the workers’ compensation insurer and was apparently a fairly good con-man, as she fooled various doctors.  However, if the employer and the adjuster had arranged for modified duty both before and after her toe surgery, would she be in jail today and would the insurer be out $1.5 million?  There is no way to know for sure, but we know from experience that the sooner an injured employee is provided modified duty, the faster the claim will come to a conclusion, and the opportunity for symptom magnification is greatly diminished. 
Original Source

Contact the Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. today if you have a workers' compensation or a Social Security disability case.
Phone: 303-595-4777
We are located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 
Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.

Privacy Policy


Friday, September 6, 2013

Employers: Know Your Work Comp Claims – Or Else! - Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. Worker's Comp Blog

By  

In comp claims, there is no substitute for knowledge of the facts. Not just the underlying facts about the injury, but the facts about how the claim is being handled.

Last week, an employer who was experiencing a rash of dubious comp injury reports had received no information from the comp board or the carrier on how the claims were being handled. The employer was also required by federal law to monitor employee injury reports and make sure that the employees could safely operate heavy vehicles. The employer, therefore, wanted to review the claim folders before the comp board, which, in NY, it has the right to do.


Employer Needs To Be Proactive To Obtain Information

But the employer did not have the board file numbers for the claims. A phone call to the carrier elicited no cooperation whatsoever. “Why do you want to know the claim numbers? Sorry, we don’t have them.” (Two of the claims were over a year old and had been to hearings.)

The employer was pleased to discover that the files could be located without the WCB number and without the carrier’s assistance or approval. The employer, however, was disturbed at the carrier’s attitude. Why shouldn’t an employer have access to the facts?

In NY, employers, until recently, were automatically notified of hearings and the the results. To be sure, that is only a bare minimum but it is a lot better than nothing. But if we go back even farther we come to a time when the carrier did not even attend hearings – just the employer. And the law has not changed since then. The employer has been gradually removed from the claim process until it has far less access to information than any other party in the process.


Employer Has Right To Full Access Of Claim Information

An employer has every right to full access to the information in a claim folder and does not need anyone’s permission to get it. But what should it do if its carrier doesn’t see things that way?

Obstructions on the information highway are like obstructions on a vehicular freeway. Don’t try to go over them or through them – and don’t put on the brakes and sit in the middle of the traffic. Instead, slow down and cautiously drive around them.

A carrier who tells an employer, “Why do you want to know?”, is inviting short pithy replies. A perfectly acceptable response might be, “Because I’m the only one paying for all this”, even if it fails to arouse sympathy. A better one is, “Because the law makes me, not you, primarily responsible for poor claim performance and harm to my workers”.

Raw information is so valuable that it is worth nearly any effort to obtain it. The employer should also be aware there are many laws that require the information that the employer needs. Comp claim information is needed for proper handling of unemployment claims, discrimination claims, private disability claims, tax matters, ERISA, ADA, FMLA, as well as a host of other laws. So an employer who is asked, “Why do you want to know”, is speaking with someone who is unaware of the comp law since its very beginnings, not to mention all the other laws passed since then.


Don’t get mad. Be patient, ask others to assist – and get the information

Contact the Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. today if you have a workers' compensation or a Social Security disability case.
Phone: 303-595-4777
We are located in the Denver Metro area.
226 West 12th Avenue Denver, Colorado 80204

Disclaimer 
Any content of this blog is intended for informational purposes only.It is not intended to solicit business, provide legal advice from The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. and does not serve as a medium for an attorney-client relationship. Therefore, The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C. is not responsible for the information on this blog which may not apply to every reader. Always seek professional counsel if you have any legal matters. Contents within the blog of The Law Office of O'Toole & Sbarbaro, P.C., logos and other related media are protected by the copyright laws of the United States and other jurisdictions.

Privacy Policy